Email link re-authentication doesn’t work

[akifumi]

Environment

• Objective C or Swift: Swift
• iOS version: 12.2
• Firebase SDK version: 6.4.0
• FirebaseUI version: 8.0.4
• CocoaPods Version: 1.7.3

Describe the problem:

Steps to reproduce:

1. Setup anonymous & email link authentication
2. Set shouldAutoUpgradeAnonymousUsers to true
3. Sign in anonymously
4. Authenticate with email link
5. Sign out
6. Sign in anonymously again
7. Authenticate with email link same as email of step4
8. Email link authentication does not work

Observed Results:

• What happened? This could be a description, log output, etc.
• The error FIRAuthErrorCodeEmailAlreadyInUse is occurred
  • https://github.com/firebase/FirebaseUI-iOS/blob/master/EmailAuth/FirebaseEmailAuthUI/FUIEmailAuth.m#L381-L387
• However success alert is displayed because completion handler does not handle FIRAuthErrorCodeEmailAlreadyInUse error
  • https://github.com/firebase/FirebaseUI-iOS/blob/master/EmailAuth/FirebaseEmailAuthUI/FUIEmailAuth.m#L355-L374

Expected Results:

• Sign in with email link succeeds

Relevant Code:

• https://github.com/firebase/FirebaseUI-iOS/blob/master/EmailAuth/FirebaseEmailAuthUI/FUIEmailAuth.m#L381-L387
• https://github.com/firebase/FirebaseUI-iOS/blob/master/EmailAuth/FirebaseEmailAuthUI/FUIEmailAuth.m#L355-L374

Thanks

[tenmar]

I have been working on a problem that I believe is exactly this issue. I have a workaround for re-authentication, but it isn't ideal: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58290744/firebase-ui-email-link-opens-app-and-is-handled-by-the-proper-method-but-does-n/58313033#58313033

I also provide more context on where the issue is occurring which can be summed up as:

• Anonymous user inputting email for email link sign in/up will cause the email link to provide a field containing the anonymous user's uid
• Handling an email link with an anonymous uid will Always cause the email auth provider to attempt to auto upgrade an anonymous user
• Attempting to auto upgrade an anonymous user to an existing email-link account will always fail
• If shouldAutoUpgradeAnonymousUsers = false, then the above will happen regardless, but in handleAnonymousUpgrade the initial check will always fail, and the email auth provider will default to handling the login attempt as if the user has tried to sign in on a different device which never signs the user in

Not sure if this is the intended outcome for this scenario, but since this issue is still open I thought I would contribute more information to help pinpoint the issue.

[russellwheatley]

Hello,

Thank you for taking the time to submit this feature request.

A new release is planned shortly for SwiftUI native Auth that replaces the previous Auth FirebaseUI, which should resolve this request. See PR: #1315

In the meantime, we will close this issue, if this is not resolved in the new version - please feel free to create a new issue.