You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Auto-complete for journals and authors field (though also allowing non-sanitized author_list option for mega-collaborative articles w/ hundreds of authors)
add new checkbox beside journal name field (& add "working paper" as a new property within article model) within article editor (see below: "Working paper" & "Under peer review" stacked & compact like prereg type radio buttons):
Other required UI tweaks:
If "In press" checked, both "Working paper" and "Under peer review" checkboxes become disabled
If "Working paper" or "Under peer review" checked, both "In press" checkbox and "Journal name" field become disabled (checking "Under peer review" already disables "Journal name")
(NOTE: "Working paper" property is not displayed as text like "Under peer review", but is solely used to group such papers under the Working paper section within an author page.)
add "+" button to navbar, with the following items: "Add article", "Add article to author page", "Add replication", "Add replication to author page"
"Add article" and "Add replication" only displayed for Admins; once article/replication saved, bring user to article's respective article page (&/or display snackbar message confirming article was added and include link to respective article page).
"Add article to author page" and "Add replication to author page" only displayed for users w/ author page & automatically links article to author page upon saving (& brings user to their author page);
for non-admin non-author page users, clicking "+" will display "Create author page" (& of course once author page created, then these users will see the 2 "Add article/replication to author page" items)
NOTE: When adding a REPLICATION from this button (for any user), open up the "New article" modal with the article type dropdown pre-selected to "Replication" (easy)
for the non-transparent exemption dropdowns, use the standard select outline component w/ label, with "None" (default), "Proprietary/IP", and "Ethical reasons" as options (to be stylistically consistent, but more importantly, to allow user to clear an exemption in case they incorrectly selected an exemption). like this (note how the label, outline, and text are lightgrey, just like the other secondary fields (e.g., Citations, views, abstract, keywords, etc.)): (easy)
improve search coverage, by searching across additional fields; currently only searches within article title and author list fields, but should also search within abstract, key words, original study (replication AT), target effect (replication AT), original article/study (reprod/robustness AT), and target article (commentary AT) fields (Fiedler & others) (moderate)
check duplicate article after leaving DOI text field OR upon DOI LOOKUP action: communicate duplicate articles via a snack bar message w/ link to pre-existing article (rather than on Save, which means a lot of wasted time for user!#@#; can later also do this for article title text field) (easy)
improve unsaved article information warnings (when BACK browser button or TAB is closed): clicking back browser button from article editor page brings back to the general rather than the author’s page (if one closes the page by clicking on the X top-left, it works fine) (M. Perugini) (easy)
improve invalid URL snackbar message & display invalid URLs in red for multiple-URL fields (article editor & author editor): ("Enter a valid URL", should mention the specific field that has the invalid URL) (or better solution is to validate URLs when "chipifying" chips; if invalid, chip is displayed in red; then if tries to save, the non-specific "enter a valid URL" snack bar message is sufficient (as is done for email addresses within Gmail's to field) (but this doesn't help with single-URL fields, so still need both solutions...) (moderate)
add "REPORT ISSUE" button to the right of article card to email us re: broken link, erroneous/incomplete information; see mockup below (which will be displayed for all users, including public-facing website) (?)
Message to display in alert type dialog: "To report an issue with this article (e.g., broken link, public data link goes to incorrect location, inaccurate/incomplete information), please contact us at curatescience@gmail.com (please specify the precise nature of the issue, thanks!)." (no title, with "DISMISS" button, and closes if ESC key pressed or user clicks outside of dialog (standard defaults for this type of dialog)
add YouTube and Vimeo videos to be displayed as embedded videos within the fancyBox media viewer, appended to any available figures; non-YouTube & non-Vimeo videos still displayed the current way (i.e., as a linked video icon under peer review information);
if no figures available for an article, then the YT/Vimeo videos will appear 1st
for now, just use a generic video thumbnail w/ video icon; later, we can automatically extract actual video thumbnail via YouTube API (though not sure if this is also possible for Vimeo videos...)
When expanding card, show hidden preprint URL (if applicable; if exposed thumbnail AND all 3 full-text links)
Mobile touch-screen issue (when exiting from media viewer): Actually 2 issues (both of which somehow do NOT happen on my laptop touch screen):
mobile-specific issue: after exiting from media viewer, must wait ~1 second before can interact w/ page?? (notice the article card shadow change after ~1 second; so perhaps just a focus issue??). I initially incorrectly thought that i had to tap on screen to be able to interact w/ page (whether trying to re-open media viewer by clicking thumbnail or even just scrolling)
safari-specific issue (iPad): waiting ~1 second doesn't matter; must scroll up or down to be able to re-click on figure thumbnail; (UPDATE: only occurs in expanded card, but NOT for exposed thumbnail in UNexpanded card)
non-admin user cannot create author page; yields following error: Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'slug' of undefined at TopBar.handle_create_author_page (webpack:///./src/components/TopBar.jsx?:246)
for the non-transparent exemption dropdowns, use the standard select outline component w/ label, with "None" (default), "Proprietary/IP", and "Ethical reasons" as options (to be stylistically consistent, but more importantly, to allow user to clear an exemption in case they incorrectly selected an exemption). like this (note how the label, outline, and text are lightgrey, just like the other secondary fields (e.g., Citations, views, abstract, keywords, etc.)):
prereg articles w/out link to prereg protocol are not correctly displaying prereg badge (& hence appear to not be sorted correctly, when in fact they are)
article page: expand replication details and commentariesAbout details (and reanalysis - reprod/robust and commentary article details; postponed because tricky to display these w/out further uglyfying the article page)
RS badge incorrectly displayed as compliant if RS selected, saved, and then removed (shows up as "None" on hover, but rather should be the unavailable grey badge).
Allow non-admin users to delete figures that they THEMSELVES added; so non-admin users cannot delete figures added by other users or admins, even if such figure appears on their OWN article (we need to be more protective here, because of current issue whereby a "rogue" user could link other researchers' papers to one's author page, and then edit/delete stuff on other researchers' articles; once we have author sanitization in place, we'll be able to be more permissive). Admins will still be able to delete any and all figures.
after modifying filters, links to article cards do not work (e.g., https://curatescience.org/app/#10.1186/s12966-019-0826-1 doesn't correctly link to "Plate size and food consumption: A pre-registered experimental study in a general population sample", which is the first article at the top after clearing all filters (same issue occurs on the search results page, eg: https://curate-science-staging-2.appspot.com/app/search?q=lebel#10.1177/0956797613486983); maybe a simple solution for linking to homepage (and search results page) article list articles is to just link to an article card's article page? (author page article card links work fine, so no need to modify these).
improve article selector so one can see the entire title (by widening the autoCompleteReactSelect component itself from 428px to 700px, and formatting title & author list/year on two separate lines like current searchbox autocomplete component; is already part of author page improvements article page improvements #64)
for multiple URL fields, entering a URL and then saving article via CTRL+S keyboard shortcut (without "chipifying" URL) does not correctly save URL (it does so correctly if saving via clicking "SAVE" button (URL is correctly chipified when "SAVE" button is clicked))
check duplicate article after leaving Title and DOI input boxes and communicate duplicate articles via snack bar message w/ link to pre-existing article (rather than on Save, which means a lot of wasted time for user!#@)
DELETING articles (ADMIN ONLY): add snack bar message confirming the deletion with clickable “UNDO” (to undo the action)
within Article selector component, HOME & END keys don’t work (useful when one wants to try a diff. key word)
improve invalid URL message on article and author editor modal (G. Nilsonne) ("Enter a valid URL", should mention the specific field that has the invalid URL) (or better solution is to validate URLs when "chipifying" chips; if invalid, chip is displayed in red; then if tries to save, the non-specific "enter a valid URL" snack bar message is sufficient (as is done for email addresses within Gmail's to field) (but this doesn't help with single-URL fields, so still need both solutions...)
improve signup/login pages
convert signup, login, and password reset pages to React pages
after successful password reset, redirect to home page
remove "Are you sure you want to sign out" warning page
one can apply transparency filters that don't apply to an article type, which then "correctly" yields "No articles match your filters" (e.g. materials badge to reprod/robust reanalysis article). but this might be a pretty involved fix, so will postpone to later (eg checking different ATs disables relevant T filters)
changing article type w/ diff. relevant badges (eg change from replication to reprod/robust reanalysis) and saving doesn't reload article list, so the filters become incorrect (very low priority given unlikely that user would do this; more likely is that user corrects a transparency badge (eg removes Materials badge because of bad link) and saves, which makes the filtered article list incorrect (but this is basically an edge case)).
yield error message if non-supported image file type is uploaded (i.e., “Image file type not supported. Only .jpg, .gif, and .png image file types are currently supported.”)
fix (lingering) issue where article selector/search (on author page) still sometimes doesn't correctly find existing articles (see: article selector (on author page) doesn't always correctly find existing articles #42 ; e.g., "lebel" doesn't find "EP LeBel, L Campbell, & TJ Loving Benefits of open and high-powered research outweigh costs", but somehow matched all other 10)
can delete sole commentaries (or media coverage) row, and then cannot add an item (but will postpone because user unlikely to do this, and can always just reopen the article editor as workaround)
unable to remove DOI and save article (no error message; use case is when incorrectly add wrong DOI for an article w/out a DOI; workaround is to delete article & start over, but non-admin users of course can't use this workaround)
commentaries don't show up for "conceptual" & commentary article types w/out T badges (though will look ugly in latter case, but this can be improved later) (actual use case: https://curatescience.org/app/article/117)
commentaries popup issue: authors/publication year incorrectly being hyperlinked to empty string for commentaries w/out a commentary URL
replication details popup issue: original study incorrectly being hyperlinked to empty string if original article URL saved & then removed
UNLINKING articles: add snack bar message confirming the unlinking with clickable “UNDO” (to undo the action)
when user logs out in different tab (or browser cache is cleared), actions requiring being logged in don't work (expected behavior: should automatically bring user to log-in screen).
automatically redirect user to page they were on before logging in (e.g., if user was on their author page, then log in, they should automatically be redirected to their author page)
surface error if admin tries to invite user w/ pre-activated author page already linked to another user (see github comment)
re-add text field adornment icons within article editor (see mockup) (easy)
(while you're at it, for the multiple-URL fields, perhaps you can display the placeholder text "Insert URL & hit ENTER" on page load rather than upon text field focus)
fix prereg & RS badge display issues: (easy)
RS badge incorrectly displayed as compliant if RS selected, saved, and then removed; it shows up as "None" on hover; instead, it should NOT be displayed at all, given that all T badges are now treated as bonus badges (see sub-issue above).
prereg articles w/out link to prereg protocol are not correctly displaying prereg badge (& hence appear to not be sorted correctly, when in fact they are)
fix commentaries not displaying when no T badges present: commentaries don't show up for "conceptual" & commentary article types w/out T badges (actual use case: https://curatescience.org/app/article/117) (easy)
fix order that video, talks, & suppl. materials URLs are displayed: order of videos URLs, talks/presentation URLs, and supplemental materials URLs are populated/linked in the opposite order; eg 1st supp. materials URL should supp. materials#1, 2nd supp. materials URL should be supp. materials#2 instead of reverse order as it is currently (LeBel) (easy)
log page views (so we can display them later): (moderate)
author page views
article page views
fix transparency filtering issues (only after all badges rendered as bonus badges, because these are intimately linked): example: filtering by "Reanalysis - Meta-analysis" and Reporting standards (RS) badge yields 2 meta-analysis articles that don't have RS badge.... (moderate)
URL link to figure from within fancyBox doesn't work from Recent page or author page, but somehow does work from an article page
update filter component (on all pages):
-add missing article types (i.e., conceptual, commentary)
-show full-screen mode papers ONLY
-filter by open peer review
deleting article from article page breaks the page (admin only); i guess navigate back to Recent page after article is deleted
improve search coverage, by searching across additional fields; currently only searches within article title and author list fields, but should also search within abstract, key words, original study (replication AT), target effect (replication AT), original article/study (reprod/robustness AT), and target article (commentary AT) fields (Fiedler & others)
order of videos URLs, talks/presentation URLs, and supplemental materials URLs are populated/linked in the opposite order; eg 1st supp. materials URL should supp. materials#1, 2nd supp. materials URL should be supp. materials#2 instead of reverse order as it is currently (LeBel)
add "Conceptual" and "Commentary" article type filters in filter component (Wolf)
add GitHub field to author page social media URLs! (& i thought there was another one...)
sorting: Addition date: Newest first vs. Publication year (M Perugini) (this was already part of author page improvements, which will be applied anywhere filter is displayed)
clarify how T & AT filters are combined (OR vs. AND) via info icon? (S Bahnik)
transparency filtering: papers w/out badge still appearing in list; this is because badge is not applicable to that article type; this will be improved in the next iteration (Touko & Wolf); but maybe additional issue, because filtering by "Reanalysis - Meta-analysis" and Reporting standards (RS) badge yields 2 meta-analysis articles w/out RS badge....
new feature: citation icon popup to easily get APA-formatted citation to article (like GoogleScholar)
within article selector (“link to existing article”), if there are no results, it incorrectly says “start typing to search”. update text to something more correct like “we found 0 results” (Wolf)
clicking back browser button from article editor page brings back to the general rather than the author’s page (if one closes the page by clicking on the X top-left, it works fine) (M. Perugini)
HELP page: explain how IMPACT is calculated (Perugini, Bishop)
add impact metric links to where impact metric info/values originates (Hasselman)
customize default T & AT filters for recent articles/newsfeed section (Hasselman)
update Author contributions placeholder text to be in line with the Credit taxonomy (&/or via an information icon on hover) linking to that format, so that we can start to standardise the contributorship model! ( a couple of people from the last SIPS meeting are working on this, e.g. myself A Van 't Veer, Alex Holcombe): https://www.cell.com/pb/assets/raw/shared/guidelines/CRediT-taxonomy.pdf
clarify Basic 4/7 RS instructions for when information is available in suppl. materials "(URLs to these linked materials must be provided in the relevant fields).” (van 't Veer)
basic 4/7 retroactive RS confusing for meta-analysis AT because most items don't apply; & 2nd (experimental conditions) item of basic 4 (retroactive) confusing for original articles not reporting experimental evidence (e.g., observational studies); UI in relation to these will be improved in next iteration (Corker)
add "info icon" (and add on HELP page) that clarifies how to fill out Basic 4/7 retroactive RS & to clarify the distinction between retroactive vs. at submission RS disclosures (M Brandt; K Corker; W Vanpaemel)
fix Basic 4/7 RS placeholder text being cut-off (van 't Veer)
# of articles incorrectly being counted (& displayed on search results page) because it is not excluding non-live articles from the count (P Moors)
automatically add "http://" to URL fields within author editor modal if the prefix is missing (though apparently this is trickier to achieve than it seems) (P Moors)
SEO optimizations for enhanced discovery of our content by Google & other web crawlers; this includes better metatags/metadata for each page, but also includes using microdata RDF tags within HTML to describe the actual content in a structured way that is "readable" to search engines & crawlers.
update title text of cited by div: from "PDF has been cited X times (as of X; Google Scholar)" to "PDF has been cited X times (as of X; Web of Science/Google Scholar)" (given crossREF DOI lookup now automatically retrieves citation counts from crossREF/WoS)
replication details popup: if only 1 replication reported, then text description should be singular, i.e.: "Article reports 1 replication of ...." instead of "Article reports 1 replications of..."
search results page: add total count of results, e.g., "10 of 20 results for xxx“ instead of current "10 results for xxx" (Fiedler)
generalize the preregistration component so that it can include a link to a trial/study registration information, which is required for all clinical trials (e.g., https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/study/NCT02452047 ) (Orban de Xivry)
author sanitization so can click on author and see all of their articles (very tricky because require this within author field in article editor, but also still accommodate raw non-sanitized author lists for mega-collaborations that have >25 authors) (Vanpaemel; McCarthy, & others)
add "info icon" for "Action editor/Reviewers" text fields, clarifying that social norms surrounding disclosing the names of AEs/reviewers is being debated/rapidly changing, hence, user should use careful judgment in disclosing such information (Heyman)
add links to article corrections/corrigenda (Wolf) (yes this seems like a useful feature, but will further clutter an already-cluttered UI (similar to adding an open "Other information" field), & work around is to just add a link to the corrigendum as a commentary to one's own article)
add "info icon" for replication details explaining what to do if replication article reports 2 replications of 2 separate studies from an original article (Wolf)
figures involving a PNG file with a transparent background are displayed as black within browser (this may not be a bug, but perhaps there's a workaround that would avoid this issue; see here) (Heyman)
Completion angle author page nudges: Show missing badges to logged-in user, but not on public-facing version of the website (KUL sep 23 meeting); yes great idea, and consistent with the "completion-angle" and gamification features that will eventually be implemented (as suggested by M Morrison);
for author page: have a VIEW that displays an author's progress/evolution in becoming more transparent OVER TIME! (love this idea!! KUL sep 23 meeting)
for more difficult/subjective metadata fields (e.g., replications), require users to have achieved a certain level of curation milestones before giving them permission to curate these more difficult fields (KUL sep 23 meeting)
inviting user issue: user clicks on invitation link but it just goes to a blank screen ("I tried with 2 browsers to access the link I was sent, but just got a blank screen."). this is a strange one that we've never observed before (out of 60 invited users, though i guess it's possible it's happened & user just didn't report it). my only theory is that she initially clicked on the invite link back in April, but then didn't sign up once on the signup page. but you'd think re-inviting her would fix it, but it didn't (and in Django admin panel, it shows her invitation "dorothy.bishop@psy.ox.ac.uk" as "ACCEPTED"). (NOTE: and this has worked w/ a few other users whose invitation link expired) ("re-inviting" = 1. delete author from Django admin panel, 2. then delete corresponding invitation, 3. then delete corresponding user, 4. then re-create author page, and 5. then re-invite from invite page)
new Article Types?:
- Data Paper (van't Veer)
- Commentary - Replication (treat as "Replication" for article type label and popup properties)
- Conceptual - Simulation
- Conceptual - Simulation - Methods/Stats
impact metric integer text fields and # of reps text field: Remove increase/decrease arrows to prevent users from entering negative values (low priority because who is even trying to click on these@@@!$#) (unsure why these were even added in the first place)
“Provide feedback” input text box on ALL pages
Auto-complete for journals and authors field (though also allowing non-sanitized author_list option for mega-collaborative articles w/ hundreds of authors)
add support to upload .pdf file type images
drag-and-drop DOI within article editor basic metadata area (see details article editor drag-and-drop details #79) (moderate)
add new checkbox beside journal name field (& add "working paper" as a new property within article model) within article editor (see below: "Working paper" & "Under peer review" stacked & compact like prereg type radio buttons):
Other required UI tweaks:
(NOTE: "Working paper" property is not displayed as text like "Under peer review", but is solely used to group such papers under the Working paper section within an author page.)
add "+" button to navbar, with the following items: "Add article", "Add article to author page", "Add replication", "Add replication to author page"
for the non-transparent exemption dropdowns, use the standard select outline component w/ label, with "None" (default), "Proprietary/IP", and "Ethical reasons" as options (to be stylistically consistent, but more importantly, to allow user to clear an exemption in case they incorrectly selected an exemption). like this (note how the label, outline, and text are lightgrey, just like the other secondary fields (e.g., Citations, views, abstract, keywords, etc.)): (easy)
improve search coverage, by searching across additional fields; currently only searches within article title and author list fields, but should also search within abstract, key words, original study (replication AT), target effect (replication AT), original article/study (reprod/robustness AT), and target article (commentary AT) fields (Fiedler & others) (moderate)
check duplicate article after leaving DOI text field OR upon DOI LOOKUP action: communicate duplicate articles via a snack bar message w/ link to pre-existing article (rather than on Save, which means a lot of wasted time for user!#@#; can later also do this for article title text field) (easy)
improve unsaved article information warnings (when BACK browser button or TAB is closed): clicking back browser button from article editor page brings back to the general rather than the author’s page (if one closes the page by clicking on the X top-left, it works fine) (M. Perugini) (easy)
improve invalid URL snackbar message & display invalid URLs in red for multiple-URL fields (article editor & author editor): ("Enter a valid URL", should mention the specific field that has the invalid URL) (or better solution is to validate URLs when "chipifying" chips; if invalid, chip is displayed in red; then if tries to save, the non-specific "enter a valid URL" snack bar message is sufficient (as is done for email addresses within Gmail's to field) (but this doesn't help with single-URL fields, so still need both solutions...) (moderate)
add "REPORT ISSUE" button to the right of article card to email us re: broken link, erroneous/incomplete information; see mockup below (which will be displayed for all users, including public-facing website) (?)
Message to display in alert type dialog: "To report an issue with this article (e.g., broken link, public data link goes to incorrect location, inaccurate/incomplete information), please contact us at curatescience@gmail.com (please specify the precise nature of the issue, thanks!)." (no title, with "DISMISS" button, and closes if ESC key pressed or user clicks outside of dialog (standard defaults for this type of dialog)
add YouTube and Vimeo videos to be displayed as embedded videos within the fancyBox media viewer, appended to any available figures; non-YouTube & non-Vimeo videos still displayed the current way (i.e., as a linked video icon under peer review information);
When expanding card, show hidden preprint URL (if applicable; if exposed thumbnail AND all 3 full-text links)
Mobile touch-screen issue (when exiting from media viewer): Actually 2 issues (both of which somehow do NOT happen on my laptop touch screen):
non-admin user cannot create author page; yields following error: Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'slug' of undefined at TopBar.handle_create_author_page (webpack:///./src/components/TopBar.jsx?:246)
for the non-transparent exemption dropdowns, use the standard select outline component w/ label, with "None" (default), "Proprietary/IP", and "Ethical reasons" as options (to be stylistically consistent, but more importantly, to allow user to clear an exemption in case they incorrectly selected an exemption). like this (note how the label, outline, and text are lightgrey, just like the other secondary fields (e.g., Citations, views, abstract, keywords, etc.)):
prereg articles w/out link to prereg protocol are not correctly displaying prereg badge (& hence appear to not be sorted correctly, when in fact they are)
article page: expand replication details and commentariesAbout details (and reanalysis - reprod/robust and commentary article details; postponed because tricky to display these w/out further uglyfying the article page)
RS badge incorrectly displayed as compliant if RS selected, saved, and then removed (shows up as "None" on hover, but rather should be the unavailable grey badge).
Allow non-admin users to delete figures that they THEMSELVES added; so non-admin users cannot delete figures added by other users or admins, even if such figure appears on their OWN article (we need to be more protective here, because of current issue whereby a "rogue" user could link other researchers' papers to one's author page, and then edit/delete stuff on other researchers' articles; once we have author sanitization in place, we'll be able to be more permissive). Admins will still be able to delete any and all figures.
after modifying filters, links to article cards do not work (e.g., https://curatescience.org/app/#10.1186/s12966-019-0826-1 doesn't correctly link to "Plate size and food consumption: A pre-registered experimental study in a general population sample", which is the first article at the top after clearing all filters (same issue occurs on the search results page, eg: https://curate-science-staging-2.appspot.com/app/search?q=lebel#10.1177/0956797613486983); maybe a simple solution for linking to homepage (and search results page) article list articles is to just link to an article card's article page? (author page article card links work fine, so no need to modify these).
improve article selector so one can see the entire title (by widening the autoCompleteReactSelect component itself from 428px to 700px, and formatting title & author list/year on two separate lines like current searchbox autocomplete component; is already part of author page improvements article page improvements #64)
for multiple URL fields, entering a URL and then saving article via CTRL+S keyboard shortcut (without "chipifying" URL) does not correctly save URL (it does so correctly if saving via clicking "SAVE" button (URL is correctly chipified when "SAVE" button is clicked))
check duplicate article after leaving Title and DOI input boxes and communicate duplicate articles via snack bar message w/ link to pre-existing article (rather than on Save, which means a lot of wasted time for user!#@)
DELETING articles (ADMIN ONLY): add snack bar message confirming the deletion with clickable “UNDO” (to undo the action)
within Article selector component, HOME & END keys don’t work (useful when one wants to try a diff. key word)
improve invalid URL message on article and author editor modal (G. Nilsonne) ("Enter a valid URL", should mention the specific field that has the invalid URL) (or better solution is to validate URLs when "chipifying" chips; if invalid, chip is displayed in red; then if tries to save, the non-specific "enter a valid URL" snack bar message is sufficient (as is done for email addresses within Gmail's to field) (but this doesn't help with single-URL fields, so still need both solutions...)
improve signup/login pages
one can apply transparency filters that don't apply to an article type, which then "correctly" yields "No articles match your filters" (e.g. materials badge to reprod/robust reanalysis article). but this might be a pretty involved fix, so will postpone to later (eg checking different ATs disables relevant T filters)
changing article type w/ diff. relevant badges (eg change from replication to reprod/robust reanalysis) and saving doesn't reload article list, so the filters become incorrect (very low priority given unlikely that user would do this; more likely is that user corrects a transparency badge (eg removes Materials badge because of bad link) and saves, which makes the filtered article list incorrect (but this is basically an edge case)).
yield error message if non-supported image file type is uploaded (i.e., “Image file type not supported. Only .jpg, .gif, and .png image file types are currently supported.”)
fix (lingering) issue where article selector/search (on author page) still sometimes doesn't correctly find existing articles (see: article selector (on author page) doesn't always correctly find existing articles #42 ; e.g., "lebel" doesn't find "EP LeBel, L Campbell, & TJ Loving Benefits of open and high-powered research outweigh costs", but somehow matched all other 10)
can delete sole commentaries (or media coverage) row, and then cannot add an item (but will postpone because user unlikely to do this, and can always just reopen the article editor as workaround)
unable to remove DOI and save article (no error message; use case is when incorrectly add wrong DOI for an article w/out a DOI; workaround is to delete article & start over, but non-admin users of course can't use this workaround)
commentaries don't show up for "conceptual" & commentary article types w/out T badges (though will look ugly in latter case, but this can be improved later) (actual use case: https://curatescience.org/app/article/117)
commentaries popup issue: authors/publication year incorrectly being hyperlinked to empty string for commentaries w/out a commentary URL
replication details popup issue: original study incorrectly being hyperlinked to empty string if original article URL saved & then removed
UNLINKING articles: add snack bar message confirming the unlinking with clickable “UNDO” (to undo the action)
when user logs out in different tab (or browser cache is cleared), actions requiring being logged in don't work (expected behavior: should automatically bring user to log-in screen).
automatically redirect user to page they were on before logging in (e.g., if user was on their author page, then log in, they should automatically be redirected to their author page)
surface error if admin tries to invite user w/ pre-activated author page already linked to another user (see github comment)
re-add text field adornment icons within article editor (see mockup) (easy)
(while you're at it, for the multiple-URL fields, perhaps you can display the placeholder text "Insert URL & hit ENTER" on page load rather than upon text field focus)
fix prereg & RS badge display issues: (easy)
fix commentaries not displaying when no T badges present: commentaries don't show up for "conceptual" & commentary article types w/out T badges (actual use case: https://curatescience.org/app/article/117) (easy)
fix order that video, talks, & suppl. materials URLs are displayed: order of videos URLs, talks/presentation URLs, and supplemental materials URLs are populated/linked in the opposite order; eg 1st supp. materials URL should supp. materials#1, 2nd supp. materials URL should be supp. materials#2 instead of reverse order as it is currently (LeBel) (easy)
log page views (so we can display them later): (moderate)
fix transparency filtering issues (only after all badges rendered as bonus badges, because these are intimately linked): example: filtering by "Reanalysis - Meta-analysis" and Reporting standards (RS) badge yields 2 meta-analysis articles that don't have RS badge.... (moderate)
URL link to figure from within fancyBox doesn't work from Recent page or author page, but somehow does work from an article page
update filter component (on all pages):
-add missing article types (i.e., conceptual, commentary)
-show full-screen mode papers ONLY
-filter by open peer review
add ability to link to a reporting guidelines document, given this seems to be becoming more common at journals (e.g., Nature, eg PDF https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41586-019-1139-x/MediaObjects/41586_2019_1139_MOESM2_ESM.pdf ; which could potentially view within the embedded viewer!!), would accommodate Penelope.ai, and also the Consensus-based transparency checklist initiative (which yields a PDF), and probably others.
deleting article from article page breaks the page (admin only); i guess navigate back to Recent page after article is deleted
improve search coverage, by searching across additional fields; currently only searches within article title and author list fields, but should also search within abstract, key words, original study (replication AT), target effect (replication AT), original article/study (reprod/robustness AT), and target article (commentary AT) fields (Fiedler & others)
order of videos URLs, talks/presentation URLs, and supplemental materials URLs are populated/linked in the opposite order; eg 1st supp. materials URL should supp. materials#1, 2nd supp. materials URL should be supp. materials#2 instead of reverse order as it is currently (LeBel)
add "Conceptual" and "Commentary" article type filters in filter component (Wolf)
add GitHub field to author page social media URLs! (& i thought there was another one...)
sorting: Addition date: Newest first vs. Publication year (M Perugini) (this was already part of author page improvements, which will be applied anywhere filter is displayed)
clarify how T & AT filters are combined (OR vs. AND) via info icon? (S Bahnik)
transparency filtering: papers w/out badge still appearing in list; this is because badge is not applicable to that article type; this will be improved in the next iteration (Touko & Wolf); but maybe additional issue, because filtering by "Reanalysis - Meta-analysis" and Reporting standards (RS) badge yields 2 meta-analysis articles w/out RS badge....
new feature: citation icon popup to easily get APA-formatted citation to article (like GoogleScholar)
within article selector (“link to existing article”), if there are no results, it incorrectly says “start typing to search”. update text to something more correct like “we found 0 results” (Wolf)
clicking back browser button from article editor page brings back to the general rather than the author’s page (if one closes the page by clicking on the X top-left, it works fine) (M. Perugini)
HELP page: explain how IMPACT is calculated (Perugini, Bishop)
add impact metric links to where impact metric info/values originates (Hasselman)
customize default T & AT filters for recent articles/newsfeed section (Hasselman)
update Author contributions placeholder text to be in line with the Credit taxonomy (&/or via an information icon on hover) linking to that format, so that we can start to standardise the contributorship model! ( a couple of people from the last SIPS meeting are working on this, e.g. myself A Van 't Veer, Alex Holcombe): https://www.cell.com/pb/assets/raw/shared/guidelines/CRediT-taxonomy.pdf
clarify Basic 4/7 RS instructions for when information is available in suppl. materials "(URLs to these linked materials must be provided in the relevant fields).” (van 't Veer)
basic 4/7 retroactive RS confusing for meta-analysis AT because most items don't apply; & 2nd (experimental conditions) item of basic 4 (retroactive) confusing for original articles not reporting experimental evidence (e.g., observational studies); UI in relation to these will be improved in next iteration (Corker)
add "info icon" (and add on HELP page) that clarifies how to fill out Basic 4/7 retroactive RS & to clarify the distinction between retroactive vs. at submission RS disclosures (M Brandt; K Corker; W Vanpaemel)
fix Basic 4/7 RS placeholder text being cut-off (van 't Veer)
# of articles incorrectly being counted (& displayed on search results page) because it is not excluding non-live articles from the count (P Moors)
automatically add "http://" to URL fields within author editor modal if the prefix is missing (though apparently this is trickier to achieve than it seems) (P Moors)
SEO optimizations for enhanced discovery of our content by Google & other web crawlers; this includes better metatags/metadata for each page, but also includes using microdata RDF tags within HTML to describe the actual content in a structured way that is "readable" to search engines & crawlers.
update title text of cited by div: from "PDF has been cited X times (as of X; Google Scholar)" to "PDF has been cited X times (as of X; Web of Science/Google Scholar)" (given crossREF DOI lookup now automatically retrieves citation counts from crossREF/WoS)
replication details popup: if only 1 replication reported, then text description should be singular, i.e.: "Article reports 1 replication of ...." instead of "Article reports 1 replications of..."
search results page: add total count of results, e.g., "10 of 20 results for xxx“ instead of current "10 results for xxx" (Fiedler)
generalize the preregistration component so that it can include a link to a trial/study registration information, which is required for all clinical trials (e.g., https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/study/NCT02452047 ) (Orban de Xivry)
author sanitization so can click on author and see all of their articles (very tricky because require this within author field in article editor, but also still accommodate raw non-sanitized author lists for mega-collaborations that have >25 authors) (Vanpaemel; McCarthy, & others)
add "info icon" for "Action editor/Reviewers" text fields, clarifying that social norms surrounding disclosing the names of AEs/reviewers is being debated/rapidly changing, hence, user should use careful judgment in disclosing such information (Heyman)
add links to article corrections/corrigenda (Wolf) (yes this seems like a useful feature, but will further clutter an already-cluttered UI (similar to adding an open "Other information" field), & work around is to just add a link to the corrigendum as a commentary to one's own article)
add "info icon" for replication details explaining what to do if replication article reports 2 replications of 2 separate studies from an original article (Wolf)
figures involving a PNG file with a transparent background are displayed as black within browser (this may not be a bug, but perhaps there's a workaround that would avoid this issue; see here) (Heyman)
Completion angle author page nudges: Show missing badges to logged-in user, but not on public-facing version of the website (KUL sep 23 meeting); yes great idea, and consistent with the "completion-angle" and gamification features that will eventually be implemented (as suggested by M Morrison);
for author page: have a VIEW that displays an author's progress/evolution in becoming more transparent OVER TIME! (love this idea!! KUL sep 23 meeting)
for more difficult/subjective metadata fields (e.g., replications), require users to have achieved a certain level of curation milestones before giving them permission to curate these more difficult fields (KUL sep 23 meeting)
inviting user issue: user clicks on invitation link but it just goes to a blank screen ("I tried with 2 browsers to access the link I was sent, but just got a blank screen."). this is a strange one that we've never observed before (out of 60 invited users, though i guess it's possible it's happened & user just didn't report it). my only theory is that she initially clicked on the invite link back in April, but then didn't sign up once on the signup page. but you'd think re-inviting her would fix it, but it didn't (and in Django admin panel, it shows her invitation "dorothy.bishop@psy.ox.ac.uk" as "ACCEPTED"). (NOTE: and this has worked w/ a few other users whose invitation link expired) ("re-inviting" = 1. delete author from Django admin panel, 2. then delete corresponding invitation, 3. then delete corresponding user, 4. then re-create author page, and 5. then re-invite from invite page)
new Article Types?:
- Data Paper (van't Veer)
- Commentary - Replication (treat as "Replication" for article type label and popup properties)
- Conceptual - Simulation
- Conceptual - Simulation - Methods/Stats
impact metric integer text fields and # of reps text field: Remove increase/decrease arrows to prevent users from entering negative values (low priority because who is even trying to click on these@@@!$#) (unsure why these were even added in the first place)
